Eight examples of the ‘uncivilized savages’ Pamela Geller is talking about

A virulently Islamophobic advertisement campaign referring to Muslims as “savage” went live this week in ten New York City subway stations. The advertisements, created and funded by Pamela Geller’s American Freedom Defense Initiative, read, “In any war between the civilized man and the savage, support the civilized man. Support Israel. Defeat Jihad.”

These are the ‘uncivilized savages’ Geller is talking about.

1. Amr the “Spider Man”

When YouTube launched a competition calling on students from around the world to develop experiments to be tested in outer space, an 18-year-old from Alexandria, Egypt, submitted a project — and won. Amr Mohamed’s experiment: to investigate how zebra spiders, which normally jump on their prey, will adapt to zero gravity. His project was among the two chosen to be carried out live by astronauts aboard the International Space Station.

Amr’s motivation stems from his fascination with science, he says, and the fact that his country hasn’t contributed much to space exploration — something he hopes to change.

Amr, by the way, is Muslim. And he’s a future scientist. Savage, right? Instead of fumbling for an answer, watch Mission Control confirm the results of his experiment.

2. Human shields for Christmas

When Egypt’s majority Muslim population promised to protect the country’s threatened Christian community, that’s exactly what it did. Thousands of Muslims gathered last year to form human barriers around churches offering Coptic Christmas eve mass services all throughout the country just days after an extremist attack left 21 dead in a church in Alexandria.

We either live together, or die together,” chanted the crowds of Muslims. Some held candlelight vigils while others cheered their Christian compatriots on as they walked through the droves and into their churches.

Two weeks later, millions of Egyptians took to the streets in nonviolent protest against the Mubarak regime. Pshaw, how silly. A civilized people would know better than to mobilize for equal rights and economic reform. Watch Egypt’s Coptic Christians return the favor as regime-loyalists and rioting thugs pelt rocks at praying Muslims. (The men shouting in the end are repeating, “They’re praying! They’re praying!” not “Jihad! Jihad!” as Pamela & Co. would like you to believe.)

3. Mohammad’s very first response on 9/11

When the Twin Towers collapsed on that fateful day, Mohammad Salman Hamdani rushed to the scene and joined the team of first responders pulling people out of the rubble. He was a 23-year old Pakistani student researcher and an NYPD cadet. He never returned home.

Mohammad wasn’t the only Muslim first responder. Dr. Rudina Odeh-Ramadan, a clinical pharmacist at the prestigious Columbia University, made it to the scene as fast as she could. She found herself buried under the rubble twice as she pulled out bodies and treated fatigued firefighters. But she was booed (in a civilized manner, so it’s cool) when she revealed her Muslim identity at a community meeting in Lower Manhattan. And when the September 11th Memorial was revealed. Mohammad’s family couldn’t find Hamdani’s name where it should’ve been: among the first responders. Although Congress declared him a hero, he was listed in a far-off panel of individuals loosely connected to the day’s events. In fact, he had even been suspected of playing a role in the attacks.

He had dreams of becoming a doctor. His mother calls him “a prime example of what it is to be a human being. He went there to save humanity.”

Mohammad’s remains were found in the wreckage of the north tower in 34 separate pieces. There is no footage of him. So instead, watch these savage tears of uncivility build up in Representative Keith Ellison’s eyes as he salutes Mohammad’s ultimate sacrifice.

4. Refugees inventing for the blind

In 2010, three 14-year-old Muslim girls from a refugee camp in Palestine invented a revolutionary cane that earned them a place (and an award) at the Intel International Science and Engineering Fair in San Jose, California, a premier competition that features the top science projects from a field of over 6 million experiments.

It took Noor Al-Arada, Aseel Abul Lail, and Aseel Al-Shaar six months to develop their cane. “Stick-tech,” they called it, uses infrared signals to identify obstacles that trigger noises and vibrations to alert blind people. The American Federation of the Blind was stunned by the invention’s capacity to resolve fundamental design errors that cane manufacturers had been struggling with since the 1970s.

The three girls wasted many days crossing Israel’s civilized checkpoints to reach Ramallah for basic supplies that weren’t available in their refugee camp. Thank God they didn’t do a jihad and expect, oh I don’t know, an end to foreign military occupation. Watch them rise above the odds.

5. Interrupting the whispers of street crime

With gun violence on the rise in Chicago, Ameena Matthews’ work is more important than ever before. She’s an “interrupter“, working the streets with local anti-violence organizations to put an end to the rampant crime that plagues many of the city’s most disadvantaged neighborhoods. It’s an innovative (and very risky) strategy that involves, quite literally, knowing how to coax a teen out of shooting his way into prison.

There is just too much to be said about Ameena, who went through her own phase of gang activity up until her twenties when she chose not to wage war on her shooters. Guided by her Muslim principles, she has six children and finds strength with her husband, an Imam at a mosque on 75th. Her work was featured in a documentary film that swept the international movie scene and the Chicago Tribune named her Chicagoan of the Year in Film.

She’s braved countless near-death experiences interrupting the whispers that could lead to a case. If everyone were as uncivil and as savage as Geller thinks she is, the world would undoubtedly be a better place to live in. Watch Ameena tell it how it is.

6. The Einstein of Structural Engineering

Skyscrapers are designed to withstand seismic activity and powerful winds but it wasn’t until the early 1960s that a structural system was designed to keep buildings from falling over without caking them in layers of concrete. The tubular design, as it was later called, was the brainchild of Fazlur Rahman Khan, a Muslim from Bangladesh who used his Fulbright Scholarship money to study in the United States. In just three years, he had earned two Master’s degrees and a Ph.D. — a feat so great that it reeks of uncivilized savagery, okay?

What really draws attention to Fazlur is his innovation. Most high-rises built since the 1960s employ some variant of his concept, including the famed Petronas Towers in Malaysia, the Bank of China Tower in Hong Kong, and even the World Trade Center towers. He personally designed the Willis Tower (formerly the Sears Tower) and the John Hancock Center, two of the tallest buildings in the United States.

Imagine how awkward it would be to catch a member of the American Freedom Defense Initiative working in any of the tall buildings built in the last fifty years that bear a Muslim’s structural brilliance. And watch this preview of a video that airs in the Willis Tower’s Skydeck that credits Fazlur’s contributions and, by default, literally falls under Geller’s definition of creeping shariah.

7. A cabdriver and his daughter do work

The Los Angeles Times published a wonderful piece two years ago by an Afghan Muslim pediatrician speaking highly about her father, a cabdriver whose dreams of becoming an engineer were crushed in the revolution of 1978. “Perhaps they see a brown man with a thick accent; perhaps they think, another immigrant cabdriver,” she writes. Or a savage, if “they” refers to Geller’s American Freedom Defense Initiative.

Waheeda Samady is a Berkeley graduate and a chief pediatric resident at a children’s hospital in San Diego. Her father is a cabdriver who begins every day with an “Inshallah,” or “God willing.” He’s been called “another Abd-ool f—–g foreigner” before but Waheeda wishes people would instead see him in her, his positive influence and his care and his efforts to raise a valuable member of society.

The two are community builders. Waheeda works with CAIR San Diego to advance relations between Muslim and American communities. She also works for Deaf communities across the city. Her father works just as hard for an honest living and is a major motivating factor for Waheeda. How’s that for incivility, eh? Watch this video featuring, among others, Waheeda explaining the importance of equal rights and civil liberties.

8. The Yuna on your iPod

Muslims contribute to society in so many ways but their contributions to popular culture are oftentimes underplayed. One particular singer and songwriter, however, defies that.

Meet Yuna, an international music icon who has dominated Malaysia’s music scene since the mid-2000s. She’s even broken into the American music scene (cue the Sharia Creepers) with music legends like Pharrell producing some of her more popular tracks.

What’s even more awesome is that she’s balanced her music career with her studies, graduating from Universiti Teknologi MARA with a Bachelor’s in Legal Studies.

Asked during an interview if her faith plays a role in her music, Yuna says that it does, that her conservative roots inspire her to write about life, love, and knowing right from wrong. If Geller isn’t careful, she might find this savagery on her iPod! Watch Yuna’s official music video for “Live Your Life”.

And so many more!

Whether or not the American Freedom Defense Initiative will retract its awful advertisements implying Muslims are naturally savage and uncivilized should be of no concern. The fact of the matter is that Muslims have played great roles in developing the technology we use, advancing the liberties that we covet, and forming life-long connections with ourselves and our neighbors. The eight examples above are but a minuscule fraction of the vast number of everyday Muslims (and everyday non-Muslims) doing everyday things to positively impact the world we live in. If Geller thinks this is savagery, well, who cares. It’s the kind of “savagery” the world needs to see more of.

There are 20 comments

  1. ontogram

    I am “for” civilization which is why I can’t side with Israel. Pam Geller, on the other hand, is formenting jihad and should not be supported as that is uncivilized.

    1. W Mahmoud

      In a nutshell, the theory here is that to legitimize Islam being uncivil will be to then associate the Palestinian people as an uncivil race. Therefore that will help decreasing the amount of heavy criticism Isreal is receiving from uprooting and murdering Palestinians as Israel takes over their more and more of Palestine’s land.

      1. ontogram

        Yes, sure — Israel will use any trick to demonize others (notably Palestinians.) This overlooks the Christian Palestinians and the secular ones, etc. Yes, that’s Israel’s purpose but this is Pam Geller in the good ole USA putting up these atrocious obnoxious posters. Do you think Pam is doing Israel’s bidding? Could that happen here in the land of the free?

      2. J T Towers

        Pam Geller’s organization is a lobbying group that wants to continue US military aid to Israel. Painting “jihad” as “savage” means that “Palestine” — the concept, — is worth being conquered. If she frames this as abstract, we are supposed to forget that Palestine is a real place with real, human people living their daily lives in it.

        Many US cities have tried to ban these ads. New York’s ban was successfully challenged on Free Speech grounds.

    2. Bob

      “ontogram” asks what Israel has to do with this? Please see Netanyahu’s speech at the UN for one example. Or look at Geller’s ad holding Israel as the paragon of civilization and contrasting Islam as “savages.” Israel likes to throw around the term “existential threat,” painting its occupation and its nukes as reasonable responses to savage non-Western mentality. Israel and its friends are working tirelessly, producing Islamophobia. That’s what Israel has to do with this.

    1. ontogram

      It’s just not nonsense in the American mind: Arabs are all Muslim and all Muslims are Jihadists. With this belief, America does things to “counter” this threat (ala Israel etc.) and thereby earns the genuine non-ideological wrath of virtually hundreds of millions of ordinary Arabs going about their lives. Like the Islamophobic lie perpetrated by Geller and Israel, this dynamic is a vicious circle of self-fulfilling prophecies, rather than anything one could call “foreign policy.”

      1. Jiří Čížek

        There are mass of christians (converted from islam) among Arabs who must keep their christianity in secret, because they would be killed if they revealed their actual faith. In Saudi Arabia there are around 20 % cryptochristians – the local police is very busy in searching Bibles in homes of people to reveal their christianity. How it would be if roles muslims vs. christians were swapped?

  2. ontogram


  3. RockyMissouri

    Thank you for all of these beautiful spirits….. I have thororoughly delighted in each story… I extend my hand in friendship, to all people…if it were left to us, there would be harmony between us, for that is what I desire.!

  4. Stephanie

    I think there are good and evil in all peoples.. that being said and recognozing the good stories above, where is the Daniel Pearl beheading? the rape and murder of good American men in Benghazi? Where is the clip of Iran wanting to annililate an entire counrty of human beings who happen to believe in a different religion? where is the story of the towers falling? pentagon burning?

    1. ontogram

      Stephpanie –These stories are cycled and recycled in the mass media. Where have you been? That’s the whole point — the reality of Islam, Iran Palestine etc.rarely seen.. The horrors of drones, “Cast Lead” in Gaza, Israel’s war on civilians, these things are not much emphasized.

      Besides, Geller is generalizing, trying to get your blood going so you will support the Zionist’s effort to steal more property and get Palestinians out of Palestine. The ad should read something like “In the confrontation between colonial occupying powers and native peoples protecting their homes, rights, their country — Support those fighting in their country for their homes!”

      Geller’s ad is obscene. Geller is obscene.

  5. Jiří Čížek

    It is nice, that there are muslims in Egypt who made the barrier to defend christians who attended church to celebrate Christmass. But are you sure there is no problem, if somebody needs “defending barrier” to practice his/her religion? Am I to consider islam as religion of peace for this?

    1. Noonie

      Keep in mind, though, the other link in that section of the Christians defending the Muslims in a similar manner. They also needed a ‘defending barrier’ to practice their religion.

  6. farenheit211

    Although individual Muslims should never be harmed because they are Muslim and some Muslims rise above their ideology and make great contributions to society, that shouldn’t stop people from making reasonable criticisms of Islamic belief, practice and culture.

    I’ve seen Israel, and I’ve seen the activities of Islamic groups in the UK and the EU. Having seen this I have no problem with referring to Islam as ‘bearded savagery’.

    Israel is not perfect, no nation is, but it is a considerably better society than any of those which are run by Islam, have Islam as its dominant culture or which allow Islam to influence its politics.

    It’s not Israel that is the problem, it’s not democracy that is the problem, it’s the bearded savagery of Islam that is the problem.

    I’m no great fan of Pamela Geller but she is right about Islam on this occasion. Islam is backwards savagery, and to treat it as anything other than that is a mistake.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s