Mansaf Debate: The case for Palestinian mansaf

Guest contribution by Jareer Kassis

Let me make it clear from the outset: I have no stake in mansaf. If it is served, I eat it; if it is not, I don’t crave it. It is reasonably tolerable on the palate if prepared correctly (more on that in a minute) but it is certainly not a delicacy that you should indulge in too often if you hope to live long enough to see your grandkids. But regardless of whether you love it or hate it, you are highly likely to encounter this behemoth of a meal if your family origins are from a town within a 100-mile radius of the Dead Sea. Therefore, my piece of advice to you is simply as follows: If you have to eat it, make sure it is made in Palestine.

I can already hear howls of protest: “But mansaf is a Jordanian dish!” Well of course it is! We Palestinians have more common sense when it comes to avoiding artery-clogging meals (well, slightly). If mansaf was good enough to be a Palestinian dish, obviously you’d have seen it offered at the Harvard Business School cafeteria next to “Israeli” hummus. No, it absolutely is a Jordanian concoction, and it is even considered the Jordanian national dish—which is fine when you realize that it is the only “national” artifact the Jordanians can claim to be proud of (considering even their national anthem sounds like an out-of-tune preamble to an actual theme that never arrives). [Read more...]

Announcing ‘The Great Mansaf Debate’

The great Palestinian student Amanda G. once said that the main reason Palestinian politics is so disjointed and disunited is because ”the people can’t agree on whether or not they like mansaf.” This is putting it lightly though. The mansaf wars are largely responsible for instigating some of the greatest tensions the Palestinian community has seen.

There’s really no middle ground when it comes to mansaf. You either love it or hate it and you will defend your position and your palate until the very end. Feelings will inevitably be hurt, rivalries will begin anew, and the uncontrolled, soggy, bread-laden rifts that develop between some of our hungrier solidarity workers and community members will carry over to other spheres of Palestinian life.

In this case, what we have in emotion we lack in rationality. We have yet to see any sanctioned and legitimate debate concerning the various influences and implications of mansaf. What we do see — quite regularly, actually — is a free-for-all hodgepodge of antagonistic and unfiltered opinionating on Twitter. (We may or may not be acquainted with the source of many of these embarrassments.) Nevertheless, a single question stands: Will there ever be an arena for prudent discourse on mansaf? The answer is an emphatic yes.

We at Sixteen Minutes to Palestine are proud to bring you The Great Mansaf Debate. In the coming months, we will present you with a variety of insights, opinions, and thoughts on mansaf and the very passionate identity-driven reactions it engenders. How can a single plate of yellow rice, greased meat, wet bread, and runny yogurt shape our community dynamic to the extent that it already does? [Read more...]

TIME selects 2012 Best Photographer for his work in Egypt, Palestine, Syria

TIME’s Photo Department faces a daunting task every year as it shuffles through millions of powerful photographs to determine the best and most dynamic photographer on the wires. This year, they honor Italian-born Marco Longari, the Jerusalem-based chief photographer for Agence-France Presse (AFP) who in just the last few months covered the revolution in Syria, the Israeli shelling of Gaza, and the persistent protests in Cairo.

His photographic tour through the Middle East took viewers on a journey of shifting political landscapes. But he focused on the human aspect of these turbulent times and managed to tell important stories. As the TIME Photo Department so aptly writes, “Longari made picture after picture this year that mattered.”

In an interview with TIME, Longari shared what he calls “the most humbling lesson in compassion” he’s experienced in his entire career. He arrived at Al-Shifa Hospital in Gaza City just after an Israeli air strike. Waiting to photograph the ensuing chaos, he phoned his family currently staying in Jerusalem but the line was cut. He managed to compose himself but the unease was still there. That’s when he felt the burden that Palestinians face on a daily basis.

Here are a small selection of his photographs. The rest can be found here.

[Read more...]

Death before liberation

He lived his entire life under occupation. Even in his few moments of freedom — which were more illusion than anything else — he was confined to a depressing reality, a fate suffered by Palestinians for decades.

I know very little detail about his final moments. I keep it vague in my head for a reason, but I don’t know what that reason is. I just choose not to ask for more. I’ll listen if someone wants to fill me in but I won’t ask. The details don’t change much because the context stays the same. He lived his entire life under occupation. He saw death before liberation, just like he used to chant.

The last time I saw him was in 2004 in his mother’s living room laying back on a loveseat sofa, legs up, cigarette in hand, hair combed back, television turned on. He had an affinity for American films, which were almost always dubbed at least three years after their release in American theaters. Sometimes I’d have to pretend I hadn’t seen the movie before. That way, he could explain the plot to me and I could be impressed by his ability to slip in the occasional English word. [Read more...]

Picture George, now picture Hamza

Guest contribution by Suha Najjar

Throughout elementary, middle, high school and even much after, we are taught and retaught to be “thankful,” to realize that we have “first-world problems” and others don’t always have what we have. And although we strive to come to terms with this, many times we forget that what we consider essential doesn’t necessarily mean that others are as fortunate to say the same. We grow up knowing what a “normal” childhood consists of. We know how children should behave, and more precisely, we know how children should not behave. Childhood has always been a necessity in our eyes. But in reality, it is a privilege that many times children themselves do not experience.

I’d like to share the story of two young boys, born and raised on two very different parts of the world. [Read more...]

When +972′s privileged journalism belittles the Palestinian struggle

Effort can be appreciated. But when the effort is spent on lazy, privileged journalism that belittles a struggle and an entire population, that is when the effort needs to be stopped in its tracks and addressed.

+972 Magazine co-founder and contributor Yuval Ben-Ami recently published a piece recounting an evening he spent watching over Gaza’s skies as Israel shelled the territory from above and as Palestinian fighters returned fire, arguably in response to the four Gazans that had been killed earlier in the day.

He had bravely chosen to leave behind his cappuccino that morning and make his way from Tel Aviv to a kibbutz just beyond Sderot, about as close to Gaza’s border as a civilian could get.

There he joined a group of likeminded photographers hoping for the best shots. In essence, they were banking on human tragedy, a military assault, quite possibly the deaths of innocent civilians, to give them a photograph and a story they could use for their own personal gain.

They waited, “looking down at impoverished, futureless Gaza and at neglected southern Israel, secretly hoping for them to burn for our amusement,” Ben-Ami writes. It is a chilling sentence. What is worse, though, is that this problematic language, its self-righteous tone, and its patronizing attitude toward Palestinians is reflected in virtually every letter of every word of every sentence in this piece.

One can easily — word emphasis: easily — make the argument that this privileged and rather offensive reportage is common to +972, because it is. But Ben-Ami has provided us with an excellent example and that is what we will examine for the time being. [Read more...]

Graphic ‘map’ reveals wealth and economic disparities between Israel and Israel-occupied Palestine

Take a look at this graphic image to get a very real idea of how Israel’s occupation drastically affects Palestinian livelihood.

Every few years, Gapminder releases an updated ‘map’ of the wealth and health of nations and non-UN members, as in the case of Palestine. It’s worthwhile to compare Israel’s economic and health status with the status of the Palestinian territories under its occupation.

Because the data considers Israel and Palestine along 1967 borders, this map presents a very stark reality. Quite literally, a person on the other side of the border (or, more appropriately, on the other side of a checkpoint) has better access to lifesaving medical treatment and an even greater chance of economic prosperity.

Some points of interest:

  • The mapped income per person in Palestine is just under $2,800 in US Dollars. The mapped income per person in Israel is over $26,000 in US Dollars. Note: These values represent adjusted GDP per capita. As the Associated Press has reported in the past, Palestine’s GDP per capita was $1,500 while Israel’s GDP per capita stood at $31,000 in 2011.
  • The world’s average income per person is at $11,000 in US Dollars. Palestine’s is significantly less; Israel’s is significantly higher.
  • The mapped life expectancy in Palestine is just under 75 years. The mapped life expectant in Israel stands at about 83 years.
  • Palestine’s wealth and health, according to this visual representation, is significantly lower than the statuses of all other reported non-UN members, including Kosovo and Taiwan.

[Read more...]

Lupe Fiasco’s ‘Food & Liquor II’ references Palestine and the cost of freedom

Co-written with guest contributor Yusef Al-Jarani

American hip hop artist Lupe Fiasco released his latest album today under the title Food & Liquor II: The Great American Rap Album Pt. 1. Known for his articulate lyricism, world consciousness, and provocative rebelliousness, Lupe uses his album to address some of society’s most acute challenges, from political corruption to media deception, war overseas to the war in our streets. Staying true to his previous work, he references Palestine, its resistance against oppression, and (indirectly) Israel’s occupation.

In “Ayesha Says”, the album’s opening track, the lyricist (an Ayesha Jaco, said to be Lupe’s sister) recites:

“Murals that salute freedom or death for liberty,
Be it Englewood or Egypt, Bedstuy or Baghdad,
Syria or Liberia, the West Bank or the West Side of Chicago,
Where food and liquor stores still occupy the block.”

In “ITAL (Roses)”, the album’s third track, Lupe raps:

But my tone was like an Afghani kid without a home,
Blew that b—h up with a drone,
An Iraqi with no daddy, Palestinian throwing stones.”
[Read more...]

Reflections on raising awareness about Palestine at the ISNA Convention

I spent the weekend at the Islamic Society of North America’s national convention, this year held in Washington, D.C, where I volunteered at the American Muslims for Palestine booth and tried my hardest to sell little handmade souvenirs. It was both a fun experience and a sad one—fun because I discovered that I do not belong in a bazaar setting, and sad because, well, the Palestinian cause felt overwhelmingly neglected and misunderstood.

I know that this kind of convention isn’t the most ideal place to gauge the general public’s interest in Palestine but I do believe that, for the segment of the American public it does attract, it’s a great opportunity to share and discuss points of relation to the cause. For Muslims worldwide, Jerusalem is not only the occupied capital of Palestine but it is also the site of the third holiest mosque.

The remainder of this post will include reflections on quotes from some of the conference attendees I met during my time at the booth.

“It’s still not over? I thought Palestine and Israel became peaceful.” — High school student

It’d only take a quick glance at Google News or any other general news site to learn that no, the occupation isn’t over yet. Let there be no illusion about it: there is no peace and there won’t be any—and justifiably so—until all human rights are restored and protected and until Israel abides by international law and takes down the apartheid regime it has pitted against the Palestinian people.

“I’m with the Palestinians but I really hate that they think everything is about them.” — College student

I remember wishing he would’ve articulated that better. He revealed that he had only recently begun to learn about Palestine and its history mostly because, he sheepishly admitted, a classmate he had once eyed for marriage was Palestinian. So what prompted his comment? Palestinians, he said, choose to be too unrelatable and self-interested. The more I dwell on his comments, the more I realize how harsh they are. Yes, there’s a general exclusivity among certain Palestinians but that is to be found in any movement really. I’d even argue that it has little to do with selfishness and much more to do with an unpreparedness to build bridges with allied movements. Of course, this is still a problem and it’s one that needs to be addressed internally and reversed externally. But these connections are a two-way thing and it is important that both sides tackle the perceived exclusivity, not just complain about it at a convention that barely addresses Palestine at all. (Only one of the more than one hundred sessions offered at ISNA this year touched on Palestine—briefly too, because the session was mostly about foreign policy as it relates to the Middle East as a whole.) [Read more...]

Sister struggles and Nasrallah’s illogical conflict of interest

Guest contribution by Eman Sahloul

As the Syrian revolution scrapes the end of its eighteenth month in protest, the loyalty war rages on outside its borders amongst government figures, activists, and “activists”. As someone very much in tune with news, rumors, and international relations—better described as the who’s-covering-who’s-butt affair—I have become particularly interested by one certain contention: Palestine, Syria, and Hassan Nasrallah.

This conflict of interest, as some may call it, has been addressed by several from a strictly political and historical standpoint. I can reiterate for maybe the eleventh time the arguments I and others have made.

I could point out once again that the Assad regime took part in peace talks with Israel in 2008, clearly contradicting its big-shot statements that Israel doesn’t exist.

I could go at length about the utter nonchalance the Assad regime displayed after Israel captured, or rather strolled into, the Golan Heights in 1967, despite how much the regime parades its resistance title.

I can refresh everyone’s seeming mental abeyance on the 1976 Tal Al-Zaatar massacre in Lebanon, where the murder of over 3,000 Palestinians was carried out by yours truly, the Syrian Army. [Read more...]

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 3,015 other followers