Irony and dilemma concerning Newseum’s decision to reverse plan to commemorate slain Palestinian journalists

The Newseum, a Washington, DC news museum, announced plans last week to memorialize 84 journalists killed in the line of duty in 2012. Included among the list of honored journalists were Mahmoud Al-Kumi and Hussam Salama who worked for Al-Aqsa TV when an Israeli air strike on November 20, 2012, killed them and at least four others. Al-Kumi and Salama were covering the Israeli invasion of the Gaza Strip when a missile hit their vehicle.

Al-Aqsa TV is the state television network for the Hamas-governed Gaza Strip.

The Newseum’s announcement drew harsh criticism from conservative and pro-Israel groups including the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) which issued a nasty statement belittling the lives of these journalists by calling their employer “not a legitimate news organization”.

On Monday, the Newseum unveiled the memorial. Instead of 84 names, it included only 82. The Newseum caved to the pressure and Al-Kumi and Salama’s names had been removed.

In a shoddy attempt at balanced news coverage of the Newseum controversy, a concept seemingly unfamiliar to Fox News, Fox decided to make its own judgment call by labeling the two Palestinian journalists as “operatives” working for Hamas. Ironically, the article headline begins with the question, “Terrorists or journalists?” as if Fox was actually going to approach the issue appropriately, tactfully, accurately, and intelligently. [Read more...]

To Israel, one man’s journalist is another man’s terrorist

Guest contribution by Deanna Othman

As Palestinians prepare to mark the 65th anniversary of al-Nakba on May 15, the date that symbolizes the beginning of the methodical dispossession and oppression of Palestinians, they have been greeted with a slap in the face by Washington, DC’s Newseum in another attempt to delegitimize and stifle their struggle.

The Newseum, which features exhibits both on news history and contemporary media technology, announced the names of 82 journalists who died covering the news in 2012, and added them to the Newseum’s Journalists Memorial in a ceremony held May 13 in the Journalists Memorial Gallery. Among the honored were Marie Colvin and Anthony Shadid, who both died in Syria.

Absent from the list of 82 journalists were an additional two names originally slated to be included — Hussam Salama and Mahmoud Al-Kumi, who were doing camera work for Al-Aqsa TV when they were killed by an Israeli airstrike in Gaza in November 2012.

The Newseum announced Monday that the museum will “re-evaluate their inclusion as journalists on our memorial wall pending further investigation.”

Although many held out the hope that the Newseum would stand by its decision, it is a grave disappointment, but not a complete surprise, that yet another institution that purports to celebrate diversity of voices has caved under Zionist pressure. [Read more...]

Fatah in Gaza: Surprised?

Hundreds of thousands of Fatah supporters gathered in Gaza City on Friday to mark the political faction’s 48th anniversary. Years of back and forth political repression meant that Fatah supporters weren’t so outspoken in Gaza and, until recently, Hamas supporters kept low profiles in the West Bank. But the real surprise, which I think many people aren’t openly admitting, has to do with the sheer size of the Fatah rally. As one colleague asked me, “since when are there that many Fatah supporters in the Strip?”

When I traveled to the Gaza Strip in 2011, I arrived under the impression that anyone with allegiance to Fatah and the Palestinian Authority would have already left to the West Bank or even to Egypt. But little did I know, just months before my arrival, as part of what I suspect to be a package deal from a previous reconciliation attempt, Hamas eased up on its limitations and allowed Gaza residents to display support for Fatah where the yellow flags and Fatah shields had previously been banned. [Read more...]

Fatah rallies in Gaza to mark faction’s 48th anniversary

Hundreds of thousands of Fatah supporters gathered in Gaza City’s Saraya Square on Friday for a mass rally to commemorate the faction’s 48th anniversary. This is the first Fatah rally at this scale to be held in Gaza since infighting between Hamas and Fatah toned down in mid-2007.

At face value, this is a good indicator that both Hamas and Fatah are scaling back on their efforts to limit or even force public opinion. It is no secret that the very notion of political dissidence in the occupied Palestinian territories is regularly met with hesitancy and competing territory-wide bans. But in the wake of Israel’s latest invasion on Gaza, Fatah — currently in control of the Palestinian Authority (PA) — and Hamas appear to have put much of the past five years aside. Another unity attempt is reportedly in the works.

I suspect there is slightly more at play here. For one thing, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu made it very clear that he wouldn’t be calling off his Pillar of Defense invasion if Gaza-based factions resist. But in just a few days he turned his reservists around and signed onto a ceasefire deal. Gaza celebrated its victory, Netanyahu’s election campaign hit a rough patch, and the PA network faced immediate humiliation for its collaboration with Israel. [Read more...]

Israeli military gives Gazans a coupon to save their own lives

The Israeli military’s horrendous PR staff put out this equally horrendous image of an announcement that, to be completely frank, reads more like a coupon. “Important lifesaver discount for the residents of the Gaza Strip” is basically what it says.

The coupon-notice tells Gazans to move away from anything Hamas-related if they’re interested in living for another day. But what happens if someone misses the coupon, if someone doesn’t move away fast enough, or if someone just decides that being a civilian should be enough to protect him or her from Israel’s haphazard bombing? Oh well. A great deal is missed and they will pay with their lives.

The announcement even has a details section that tells when and where this coupon is valid.

This is just one component of a greater social media campaign that Israel has attached to its invasion of Gaza, hoping, it seems, that it’ll counter the criticism it is bound to receive for its indiscriminate targeting of Gazan civilians.

For a brief timeline on Israel’s escalation since early November, visit this page. At the time that I am writing this, news has just been confirmed of a series of explosions in Beit Hanoun that left three Palestinian children dead, aged 9, 14, and 16 years old.

Eyewitness account of Israel’s air invasion of Gaza

A cousin of mine in Gaza City recounted to me his experience under Israeli assault over the course of the last few days. He explained how the shelling had affected him and his family and how anxiety levels were high as Gazans prepared for an onslaught reminiscent of the one that happened almost four years ago.

This evening I found an opportunity to get in touch with Fahed, a cousin just one year younger than me but who has been tried and tested far more than I ever will be. I asked him to give me a status update. He would only ask how my family was doing in the States, as if this was a casual talk with nothing going on in the background.

But by now, Israel had been striking Gaza for seven days beginning on Thursday, November 7, after an Israeli air strike killed a 12-year-old boy playing soccer in the streets. The attack had broken a two-week lull in violence.

Armed militias in Gaza responded with crude rocket fire while the Israeli military expanded its operation and continued the air strikes, taking down building after building and killing upwards of 10 civilians, including children, reports say.

An Egypt-brokered ceasefire went into effect but it only lasted two days before Israel launched a targeted assassination of Ahmad Jabari, a commanding officer of Hamas’s military wing. The strike had effectively broken the ceasefire and the violence erupted just as quickly.

Over the course of the day, the Israeli military launched dozens of air strikes in conjunction with a shelling campaign that mobilized warships just off of Gaza’s coasts. Meanwhile, resistance militias resumed rocket fire. [Read more...]

Nice try: Terrible reasoning for why Israel should cut Gaza’s power supply

Consider this a Nakba special. Here, an individual (to be initialed AE) presents his reasoning for why Israel should cut power supplies to the Gaza Strip this coming summer to make up for any of Israel’s power deficiencies. His text will be in bold. My responses will be in italics.

Israel isn’t directly at fault for the lack of power in Gaza. True, Israel did bomb the power plant in 2006 but its been 6 years and, while Israel (and Egypt) attempted to stop building materials from getting into Gaza they were obviously unsuccessful (there was plenty of smuggling as evidenced by the huge amount of rockets fired from Gaza (just from the beginning of 2007 until mid-June of 2008 there were 4,117 rockets fired from Gaza)

Right off the bat, a contradiction. This is going to be good. First, AE contends that Israel is not to be held responsible. But then he immediately cites the 2006 bombings that destroyed much of the main power system in the Gaza Strip. And let us not forget the carnage of 2008-2009 that intentionally damaged Gaza’s power grid. Thinking he can get away with seeming so intellectual, AE also throws in some stats: 4,117 rockets fired from Gaza from 2007 to 2008. What he forgets to mention is Israel fired 14,617 heavy artillery shells into Gaza in just 18 months, from September 2005 to May 2007, according to Human Rights Watch.

Presumably, the Gazans could have used the building material for a power plant but, once again, they prioritized murdering Israeli civilians over caring for their own citizens.

I take it AE doesn’t consider it murder when a uniformed military force lays siege to a surrounding strip of territory for twenty-two straight days.

Israel should not be obligated to give free electricity to those who chose to use the building materials that could have been used to create that electricity in order to attempt to kill as many of the civilians who are providing the electricity as they can.

First, Israel does not “give free electricity”. It sells it. By this point, one would assume this is common knowledge. And second, maybe this is just a grammatical concern of mine but AE should learn how to construct complex sentences with more than one object. In this case, civilians are not the ones providing electricity. [Read more...]

A brief deconstruction of “Sh*t People Say About Israel”

Pro-Israel students, under the guidance of The David Project, recently joined the “Sh*t [people] say” internet craze on YouTube with their own video, “Sh*t People Say About Israel”. Filmed at the University of Illinois at Chicago, the film clearly takes aim at supporters of the Palestinian cause and patronizes them as ignorant and misinformed. But the video fails on so many levels. Let’s see what kind of “Sh*t” these student hasbarists have to say.

1. Israel doesn’t even want peace.

If it did, it probably wouldn’t be incarcerating children or building concrete barriers through Palestinian villages or preventing Arabs from marrying Israelis or arming fanatical settlers colonizing the West Bank or demolishing homes or tearing through olive tree groves or shooting high velocity tear gas canisters at the faces of unarmed demonstrators.

2. I heard everyone there is in the army.

In Israel, military service is compulsory for all citizens above the age of 18. Recruits serve between two and three years and are given the opportunity to extend their service. Clearly, not everyone in Israel is in the military at any given moment, but the mandatory service means that most adult citizens have, at one point or another, served as an active military unit involved in the maintenance of a condemned and illegal occupation of Palestine.

Mind you, there does exist a refusenik subculture in Israel, but unless these individuals refuse to join the military for religious reasons, they are often stigmatized and prosecuted under Israeli law. Maya Wind, for example, spent forty days in a military prison for refusing to join the Israeli military on the basis that she could not agree with the military’s illegal activity towards the Palestinian people.

[Read more...]

All quiet on the homefront after pro-Israel editor suggests assassinating the President

I wonder what will happen to the man who calls for the assassination of the President of the United States. The post-9/11 era dictates that the mere thought of something so absurd, something so backwards, merits serious consequences. The Department of Homeland Security elevates the national threat level. A Patriot Act-like bill pushes its way through Congress. Those associated with the plot are arrested, interrogated, sent to Guantanamo, and kept there. The President is safe.

But I’ve left out one blaring detail that has the power to quell Washington’s reaction: the man’s political and religious affiliation. [Read more...]

Letter to Gilad Shalit’s family and supporters

To Gilad Shalit’s family and  supporters,

Your son has returned home; congratulations. I’m sure you are relieved, and deservedly so. You’ve waited five long years for this day, to be able to see your son in the flesh. Today he stands before you, and now I do too.

I want to ask you an honest question. Irrespective of the fact that Shalit is your son or your neighbor or a young man, has justice really been done? It doesn’t require a stretch of imagination to say yes. Shalit returned home, and within the coming days, so will 1027 Palestinians. But the real answer is no.

This prisoner swap has yet to challenge the status quo. Tonight, thousands of Palestinian Shalits, figuratively speaking, will sleep in Israeli jails. Tomorrow, they will wake up, still locked behind bars and basement walls. They will wonder why the world hasn’t taken them as seriously as the real Gilad Shalit, the Israeli one whose blood is apparently much more valuable than theirs. They will wait. Another day will pass; they will sleep and repeat.

I want to ask another question. Do you see anything wrong with this picture? Collectively, the freed Palestinians are painted as mass murderers concerned with nothing else but a second chance to target the Israeli state while Shalit is hailed as a champion, an innocent bystander uninvolved in the upkeep of the occupation and accidentally donning a military uniform the day he was captured. [Read more...]

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 3,016 other followers