‘I agree with you that everyone is deserving of human rights, however…’: Anti-Palestinian talking points squashed at U of Chicago SJP event

Students for Justice in Palestine at the University of Chicago hosted a panel titled “The Question of Palestine” on Thursday to address the viability and practicality of the one and two-state solutions in light of the Palestinian Authority’s recent United Nations bid and Israel’s continued settlement expansion. The panel featured distinguished journalists and thinkers Yousef Munayyer, Mitchell Plitnick, and Ali Abunimah, and was moderated by John Mearsheimer.

During the Question & Answer session, a student identified by the school newspaper as a member of Chicago Friends of Israel, the university’s pro-Israel student group, challenged Abunimah’s position on the one-state solution and accused him of “vehemently oppos[ing] a Jewish state”. The two went back and forth, with Abunimah showing the inherent contradictions in the student’s claim and the student pushing overused talking points about Hamas.

The footage begins just after the student asked her first question and when Abunimah began to answer. She questioned Abunimah’s stance on a Jewish homeland and incorporated “13,000 rockets” into her question.

(Note: When a full version of the footage becomes available, it will take the place of the footage below.)

Ali Abunimah: — questions for me are circulated by StandWithUs. Is that where you got them?

Student from Chicago Friends of Israel: Actually, no. I formulated these on my own.

AA: Sorry?

Student: I formulated these on my own. [Read more...]

U of Michigan students to dismantle the myths of Israeli democracy

Guest contribution by Farah Erzouki

This Thursday, January 26, Students Allied for Freedom and Equality (SAFE) at the University of Michigan — Ann Arbor will be bringing renown author, journalist, and commentator Ali Abunimah for a groundbreaking lecture discussing, “Colonial Reality: Dismantling the Myths of Israeli Democracy. Abunimah, co-founder of Electronic Intifada and author of One Country: A Bold Proposal to End the Israeli-Palestinian Impasse, will address the campus community on the reality of Israel’s claim as the region’s only beacon of light, a terms it regularly assigns to itself. (Editor’s note: Event information can be found at the end of this post.)

Rhetoric surrounding the Israel-Palestine conflict has continuously revolved around the argument that Israel is the only democracy in the Middle East. Such claims are not only false and biased, but have harsh implications in terms of the public opinion regarding the question of Palestine. These falsehoods propagated by the media and other outlets have lead to the pardoning of Israel for their blatant racist, discriminatory and colonizing practices and have characterized the Israeli government as the only nation in the Middle East that has any promising future because of its democratic ideals. These falsehoods lead to the Israeli exceptionalism that we see so often. Forgetting about the war crimes, violations of international law, illegal occupation and ethnic cleansing of a people, we see figures of power praising Israel for democratic traits they do not truly possess. We hope that this event will shine light on the realities of the that most college-age students at a public university may never hear. This topic is crucial because it will, as the title suggests, dismantle the myths that have been propagating popular opinion. [Read more...]

SJP UChicago addresses Israel’s confusion on how the invasion of Gaza backfired

There is no doubt in my mind that Israel is utterly confused with the outcome of its invasion of Gaza three years ago. First, Gaza hasn’t yet collapsed into a state of abject humanitarian dispair. Yes, support for Hamas has waned since then but Hamas’ political stability does little to accurately represent the resilience of the territory’s population.

Second, the case against Israel is mounting. After denying all accountability for violating dozens of international law treatises and human rights accords and after managing to convince the once honorable Richard Goldstone to argue against himself, Israel is forced to reckon with the fact that criticism against its policies towards Palestinians in general continues to grow in terms of scope, material evidence, and support.

Third, the siege that remains over Gaza even though Gilad Shalit is out of Hamas’ custody has encouraged debate within Israel. The disillusionment that manifests itself in the minds of those who finally see the occupation for what it is inspires discontent. Israel’s social protests do a tremendous job of ignoring Israel’s treatment of Palestinians so I will not say that the internal debate it encourages has in mind the best possible solution for Palestinian sovereignty, but I will say that the emergence of a social consciousness within at least a few sectors of Israeli society was not on the government’s agenda. Twenty-two days of righteousness in 2008-2009 went down the drain, just like that. [Read more...]

Jerusalem Post news editor denies existence of Palestinians

Would you trust a news source if it explicitly breeds hatred and intolerance? What if it attempts to manipulate or even ignore the truth? Or how about if it justifies the oppression it has a moral duty to report on?

Deputy news editor of the Jerusalem Post Israel Kasnett is caught in a very awkward spot. It is unfortunate to see that although the public entrusts him and his staff of journalists to accurately portray the news without indulging in any bigoted  ideologies, Kasnett finds it acceptable to promote his fundamentally flawed belief that “63 years ago [P]alestinians did not exist!!!”

Kasnett’s remark, published through Twitter, came as a response to Electronic Intifada co-founder Ali Abunimah’s statement that after sixty-three years, Israel now has its very own “massive ghetto prison for the ethnically cleansed, called Gaza”. Kasnett’s remark also serves as the critical foundation for the denial of the Nakba in which upwards of 800,000 Palestinians were forcefully removed from their homes in 1948. [Read more...]

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 3,015 other followers