Why Palestinians won’t lend their voices to OneVoice and liberal Zionism

Guest contribution by Sami J.

The organization OneVoice claims to be a grassroots movement aimed at empowering Israelis and Palestinians to push their leaders toward a two-state solution. In practice, this has translated into a strategy overwhelmingly focused on what’s good for Israel — and specifically Israel’s Jews — while Palestinian suffering and rights are sacrificed on the altar of compromise. This problem was pointed out by PACBI back in 2010. And last week, it was thrown into stark relief when it was discovered that OneVoice had put out a shockingly racist Hebrew-only graphic, warning of the increase in the Palestinian population and what counteractions must be taken to preserve a Jewish majority in historic Palestine (a full translation can be found here).

In what can only be described as naked cynicism, while OneVoice was warning Israeli Jews of the “high” number of Palestinians, it was also seeking to collaborate with Palestinians in exile, specifically the Chicago Movement for Palestinian Rights (CMPR), a youth-led Palestine solidarity organization. CMPR understandably refused, issuing an open letter outlining their valid reasons. This did not sit well with liberal Zionist professor Mira Sucharov, who wrote a very patronizing piece on the need to refrain from (what she thinks are) frivolous accusations of racism and to work together to achieve peace (on Zionist terms, of course) instead.

When I challenged her on this, she responded that while she understands OneVoice’s message “stings”, Jewish yearning for national sovereignty is also important; and that the disagreement with OneVoice is “about feelings and narrative” where “collective emotions and historical memory are key”. [Read more...]

Mansaf Debate: The case for Palestinian mansaf

Guest contribution by Jareer Kassis

Let me make it clear from the outset: I have no stake in mansaf. If it is served, I eat it; if it is not, I don’t crave it. It is reasonably tolerable on the palate if prepared correctly (more on that in a minute) but it is certainly not a delicacy that you should indulge in too often if you hope to live long enough to see your grandkids. But regardless of whether you love it or hate it, you are highly likely to encounter this behemoth of a meal if your family origins are from a town within a 100-mile radius of the Dead Sea. Therefore, my piece of advice to you is simply as follows: If you have to eat it, make sure it is made in Palestine.

I can already hear howls of protest: “But mansaf is a Jordanian dish!” Well of course it is! We Palestinians have more common sense when it comes to avoiding artery-clogging meals (well, slightly). If mansaf was good enough to be a Palestinian dish, obviously you’d have seen it offered at the Harvard Business School cafeteria next to “Israeli” hummus. No, it absolutely is a Jordanian concoction, and it is even considered the Jordanian national dish—which is fine when you realize that it is the only “national” artifact the Jordanians can claim to be proud of (considering even their national anthem sounds like an out-of-tune preamble to an actual theme that never arrives). [Read more...]

Nothing Left to Say: It’s Time to Act to Prevent Forced Displacement in the South Hebron Hills

Guest contribution by Joy Ellison

There is nothing left to say about Israel’s occupation of Palestine.

Over the last 64 years, more than enough ink has been spilled decrying Israel’s human rights violations against Palestinians. At this point, no one can claim not to know what is happening. There is no need to continue writing about the 25-foot-high wall that snakes throughout the West Bank or the checkpoints slow Palestinian daily life to a crawl. There is no need to write more about the illegal Israeli settlements that perch on the hills of Palestine or the thousands of Palestinians held inside Israeli prisons. Whatever journalists write, nothing changes. Nothing, except the number of Israeli settlers and the number of Palestinian political prisoners, both of which grow daily. In the face of these grim realities, what can any of us say? It’s all been said before.

Israel’s politicians and military authorities themselves seem to be out of fresh ideas. Here in the South Hebron Hills, Israeli occupation authorities are reprising their favorite strategies as they continue their efforts to drive Palestinian communities out of the area. On December 4, soldiers demolished the mosque in the village of Mfagraha for the second time. The threat of demolitions is always present in this rural area. One member of the village reports that an Israeli soldier told him, “Today we demolish the mosque but as soon as we get the court order we will demolish your house as well.” [Read more...]

A look into the step-by-step process of Palestinian embroidery

Guest contribution by Rana Nazzal

Tatreez, or embroidery, is a Palestinian tradition deeply rooted in the history and culture of Palestine. It is a form of art and a language of expression. If we study the symbols and patterns of each area of Palestine, we can witness the connection of the Palestinian people to their land. Tatreez depicts not only the surrounding nature but also rites of passages and historical events. It is deeply historical but has also evolved as Palestine has been colonized, ethnically cleansed, divided, and occupied.

For me, preserving our embroidery is congruent with preserving our identity and telling our story. I live in the diaspora only because my father was forcefully evicted from his home in Tabaria in 1948. Although I am denied my homeland I maintain my identity through our traditions, including the practice of tatreez. Through each stitch I feel closer to what has been denied to me and I embed a deeper hope to one day return.

[Read more...]

Thoughts on the Newtown shooting from halfway around the world

Guest contribution by Syazwina Saw

Living on Twitter is a precarious existence.

Events do not manifest themselves well in just 140 characters. What you get are soundbites and facts, retweeted as endorsement or vilification, made popular by approval or mockery. When I joined Twitter in the end of 2008, I became a spectator to the Iranian revolution which died almost as soon started. And then there was Egypt, which continues to be a battlefield of ideals, beliefs and morals. Sometimes we fixate on details. Sometimes these prove to be insights.

And when you live several continents away from the United States, as I do, then waking up in the morning means bracing yourself for whatever happened eight hours ago. Before I went to bed on Friday night, I saw tweets of people sending prayers to Newtown, but without further detail.

And we woke up to the news of 20 children murdered at school.

Names and ages of the victims of the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting in Newtown, California, published on the front page of the New York Times.

Names and ages of the victims of the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting in Newtown, California, published on the front page of the New York Times.

My timeline today is a picture of shared grief, horror and disbelief. It is an outpour of sympathy and vilification, of prayer and condolences, of anger and blame. The online debate immediately turned to gun control and mental health, and within the heady brew of blood and politics, a few facts are mentioned again and again:

Eighteen hours before the shooting in an elementary school in Newtown, Connecticut, Michigan’s State Senate pushed through a bill which allows people to carry a gun or rifle into schools and kindergartens. Obama continues to champion the use of drones in Afghanistan and other countries in order to target terrorists, but which generates a high number of civilian casualties, many of them children. Israel continues to receive funding from the US, most of which goes into the Israeli Defense Forces – two days ago, an IDF soldier killed 17-year-old Muhammad Al-Sulaymah who was bringing home a cake to celebrate his birthday. [Read more...]

‘We do not correct martyrs; it is they who correct us’

Guest contribution by Dina Elmuti

G-exam

A teacher in Gaza’s University College of Applied Sciences corrects an exam belonging to one of their students who was massacred earlier this month during Israel’s onslaught of the coastal enclave. “Dear Martyr: I apologize for not correcting your exam papers. We do not correct martyrs; it is they who correct us.”

When I saw this photo today and read the haunting words written by this teacher, my heart was overcome by overwhelming heaviness and a feeling of shame and inescapable guilt. It was a caustic reminder of the piercing and devastating struggles that students in Gaza face daily. A walloping and humbling slap in the face, I needed to be reminded. [Read more...]

Picture George, now picture Hamza

Guest contribution by Suha Najjar

Throughout elementary, middle, high school and even much after, we are taught and retaught to be “thankful,” to realize that we have “first-world problems” and others don’t always have what we have. And although we strive to come to terms with this, many times we forget that what we consider essential doesn’t necessarily mean that others are as fortunate to say the same. We grow up knowing what a “normal” childhood consists of. We know how children should behave, and more precisely, we know how children should not behave. Childhood has always been a necessity in our eyes. But in reality, it is a privilege that many times children themselves do not experience.

I’d like to share the story of two young boys, born and raised on two very different parts of the world. [Read more...]

Life and Death and Life Again in Gaza

Photographs by Mosa’ab Elshamy

[Read more...]

Goodbyes are never easy

“One Occupied Gazan Summer” is a three-part personal narrative by Mariam I. who explores her thoughts and retraces her steps during her most recent visit to the Gaza Strip. Read part one here and part two here.

Part three of three. One of the most painful moments of my summer was sharing a tearful farewell with my mother the morning she was set to leave Gaza through Egypt, one week before her flight to the United States. I woke up, got dressed for work, and went to the side of her bed to tell her two months was not long enough to be sad about not seeing each other and that before we’d miss each other, I’d be rejoining her in the United States.

Before I could say any of those things, my mother’s tears were streaming down her face. I knew that as hard as it was for her to leave Palestine, it was harder for her to leave me there, uncertain of my safety. I hugged her, told her I’d miss her, and asked her to have a safe trip before I ran out of the room as quickly as I could. She couldn’t see me cry; I had to be strong so she wouldn’t worry. Goodbyes are never easy.

I cried in the stairwell and as I walked down the unpaved road in front of the house. I was able to compose myself in time to not look crazy before I had to hail a taxi. That was a difficult day of work. I found myself constantly searching the news for information on the status of the Rafah Crossing. How many busses were let through, how may were sent back, how many people were trapped in the lobby waiting to cross into Egypt?

I was terrified; my mother’s flight was approaching and she needed to get through as soon as possible, but also, I didn’t want to have to deal with another painful goodbye. I went home from work that day in the same depressed state that I arrived in. I entered the house and went straight for the kitchen, but oddly, I imagined my mother’s laugh. [Read more...]

Thank you, Israel, for your lifesaving diet

Guest contribution

To Israel,

Thank you, Israel, for helping us avoid a humanitarian crisis. Without your help in calculating how many calories I as a Gazan should consume, I would probably fall victim to some unexpected calamity. Imagine what would happen if all 1.7 million of us were left to live on our own without knowing exactly how many calories and how many grams of food are allocated to us. We’d probably overeat ourselves to death. And just like that, an entire population of natives would be gone — a thought, I am sure, that has never once crossed your mind.

You really saved us this time, didn’t you.

I learned that a district court ordered your Ministry of Defense to release the documents detailing how you calculated these lifesaving diets. Why’d they have to pry it out? Why did you keep it such a secret? If I was saving someone from the brink of humanitarian disaster, I’d be excited to share the news. Who knows, maybe others would follow.

But you. You kept your noble mission secret. Just the kind of humility and selflessness we’ve come to expect from the Israel that despises the fancy lights and the glitter and the global attention. You consistently redefine the concept of altruism and the way you interact with Palestinians should be a model for worldwide social interaction. It’s not every day that a country voluntarily dedicates its top officials to meticulously calculate, outline, and enforce a way of life for millions of others. [Read more...]

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 3,015 other followers