Irony and dilemma concerning Newseum’s decision to reverse plan to commemorate slain Palestinian journalists

The Newseum, a Washington, DC news museum, announced plans last week to memorialize 84 journalists killed in the line of duty in 2012. Included among the list of honored journalists were Mahmoud Al-Kumi and Hussam Salama who worked for Al-Aqsa TV when an Israeli air strike on November 20, 2012, killed them and at least four others. Al-Kumi and Salama were covering the Israeli invasion of the Gaza Strip when a missile hit their vehicle.

Al-Aqsa TV is the state television network for the Hamas-governed Gaza Strip.

The Newseum’s announcement drew harsh criticism from conservative and pro-Israel groups including the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) which issued a nasty statement belittling the lives of these journalists by calling their employer “not a legitimate news organization”.

On Monday, the Newseum unveiled the memorial. Instead of 84 names, it included only 82. The Newseum caved to the pressure and Al-Kumi and Salama’s names had been removed.

In a shoddy attempt at balanced news coverage of the Newseum controversy, a concept seemingly unfamiliar to Fox News, Fox decided to make its own judgment call by labeling the two Palestinian journalists as “operatives” working for Hamas. Ironically, the article headline begins with the question, “Terrorists or journalists?” as if Fox was actually going to approach the issue appropriately, tactfully, accurately, and intelligently. [Read more...]

To Israel, one man’s journalist is another man’s terrorist

Guest contribution by Deanna Othman

As Palestinians prepare to mark the 65th anniversary of al-Nakba on May 15, the date that symbolizes the beginning of the methodical dispossession and oppression of Palestinians, they have been greeted with a slap in the face by Washington, DC’s Newseum in another attempt to delegitimize and stifle their struggle.

The Newseum, which features exhibits both on news history and contemporary media technology, announced the names of 82 journalists who died covering the news in 2012, and added them to the Newseum’s Journalists Memorial in a ceremony held May 13 in the Journalists Memorial Gallery. Among the honored were Marie Colvin and Anthony Shadid, who both died in Syria.

Absent from the list of 82 journalists were an additional two names originally slated to be included — Hussam Salama and Mahmoud Al-Kumi, who were doing camera work for Al-Aqsa TV when they were killed by an Israeli airstrike in Gaza in November 2012.

The Newseum announced Monday that the museum will “re-evaluate their inclusion as journalists on our memorial wall pending further investigation.”

Although many held out the hope that the Newseum would stand by its decision, it is a grave disappointment, but not a complete surprise, that yet another institution that purports to celebrate diversity of voices has caved under Zionist pressure. [Read more...]

Excellent sentence by The Guardian on Stephen Hawking’s boycott of Israel (with bonus at the end)

World-renouned theoretical physicist Professor Stephen Hawking joined the boycott of Israel on Tuesday by withdrawing from a conference hosted by Israeli president Shimon Peres in Jerusalem.

The announcement was met with ferocious (and nonsensical) pressure from backers of Israel’s occupation. In one case, an Israeli law firm, Shurat HaDin, condemned Hawking’s decision to join the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement as “hypocritical”, arguing that the computers he uses contain technology designed by Israeli tech engineers.

Rather than addressing Hawking’s concern about the rights of Palestinians as well as Israel’s frequent and disproportionate use of force against Palestinian civilians, the critics chose instead to bring attention to Israeli technological or scientific contributions. It is as if these advancements grant Israel free reign to violate international law (via settlement building, occupation, etc.), civil rights (via minority rights, race-based deportations, etc.), and human rights (via movement restrictions, incarceration of children, etc.).

Luckily, Hawking isn’t bending. Whitewashing and rebranding Israeli human rights and international law violations, and attempting to guilt BDS advocates by skewing the focus of the boycott call is wholly unsuccessful. [Read more...]

Repudiation of the West does not define Islam

Guest contribution by Deanna Othman

On May 1, Foreign Policy magazine published a piece by Yair Shamir with the headline “Our Shared Islamist Enemy: From Boston to Israel, radicals are attempting to destroy Western culture.”

Shamir’s piece endeavors to draw baseless parallels between the Boston Marathon bombings and the resistance of Palestinians against the Israeli occupation, what he inaccurately portrays as an “aggressive and offensive jihad, unconnected to any particular conflict or borders, which conjoins Islamist terror groups around the world.” His unabashedly Zionist agenda rears its head through this opportunistic attempt to play into the media circus surrounding the Boston bombings.

His ludicrous argument essentially states that the problem is not Hamas or Al Qaeda, the problem is not Osama Bin Laden or Dzokhar Tsarnaev: the problem is Islam.

Unfortunately, the Boston bombings have given virulent propagandists and Islamophobes a field day. While various pundits and media personalities jumped to the Tsarnaev brothers’ religious identities as the singular motive for their alleged acts of violence, they focused on them as individuals, and how their thought processes could have been perverted by purported religious radicalization. What makes Shamir’s contention particularly disturbing is his sweeping generalization that all groups and individuals affiliated with Islam, from Hamas to the Muslim Brotherhood, to the Tsarnaevs and Sayyid Qutb, all had a particular end in mind—the obliteration of Western culture. [Read more...]

Iran can teach the world a thing or two about charity, and markets

While preparing for a final paper for my Organ Transplantation course, I came across this wonderful paragraph about the aptly-named “Iranian model” of organ allocation:

“Only one country, Iran, has eliminated the shortage of transplant organs—and only Iran has a working and legal payment system for organ donation. In this system, organs are not bought and sold at the bazaar. Patients who cannot be assigned a kidney from a deceased donor and who cannot find a related living donor may apply to the nonprofit, volunteer-run Dialysis and Transplant Patients Association (Datpa). Datpa identifies potential donors from a pool of applicants. Those donors are medically evaluated by transplant physicians, who have no connection to Datpa, in just the same way as are uncompensated donors. The government pays donors $1,200 and provides one year of limited health-insurance coverage. In addition, working through Datpa, kidney recipients pay donors between $2,300 and $4,500. Charitable organizations provide remuneration to donors for recipients who cannot afford to pay, thus demonstrating that Iran has something to teach the world about charity as well as about markets.” (Emphasis mine.)

This comes from an article published in January of 2010 at a time when anti-Iran hysteria was well beyond its infancy but nowhere near as visible as it is today. [Read more...]

Educational apartheid: Schoolteacher Nour Joudah denied the right to enrich Palestinian minds

N Joudah empty class

Nour Joudah, 25, a Palestinian-American high school teacher at the Ramallah Friends School was denied entry into Israel last week. This marked the second time in two months Israel denied Joudah the right to enrich the minds of her students.

Joudah left Palestine for a short vacation at the end of the last semester but was refused entry into the West Bank when she returned. She held out in neighboring Jordan and attempted to fly into Ben Gurion Airport on February 25. She was denied entry again.

The following day, she emailed her ninety students a final goodbye.

This is educational apartheid, deliberate and subversive. The Palestinian school system has come under attack designed to chip away at the potential of the youth — the potential to overcome Israel’s occupation.

In Gaza just four years ago, Israel showed a propensity to bomb schools outright. Today, it is similarly becoming more outward in its sabotage of Palestine’s educational infrastructure. It now does what it can, whenever it can, to restrict Palestinian children’s accessibility to knowledge, skill, expertise, and guidance. [Read more...]

Avi knows best

What. This was his actual response.

Apparently Jewish Agency official Avi Mayer knows best. Dispossessed Palestinians should be relieved that they don’t have to face traffic jams. Palestinians not allowed to drive on Jewish-only or settler-only roads (which Mayer doesn’t believe exist) are lucky they get to use roads leading through — or stopping at — personally invasive security checks and military checkpoints. Thank you for saving us, colonists.

I’m not allowed into the West Bank. Neither is Nour, a Palestinian-American schoolteacher who teaches English to students in Ramallah. Wedad and millions of other Palestinians are also kept out. But hey, they “aren’t missing out on much,” thank God.

One Amazon user’s absurd review of ’5 Broken Cameras’

Award-winning film 5 Broken Cameras is now available on Amazon, much to the excitement of those interested in owning their own copy of this extraordinary account of life under occupation. With people capitalizing on the momentum of its Oscar nomination, the film has become the most popular foreign film and the fifth most popular documentary film sold on Amazon.

At this moment, 5 Broken Camera’s Amazon page has registered 18 reviews to give a very favorable average of 4.7 out of 5 stars. But this number would be closer to 4.9 stars if it weren’t for J. J. Surbeck, Amazon’s resident one-starer who is convinced Palestinians are figments of our wildest imaginations.

Surbeck’s review begins with a gross generalization about how “all pro-Palestinian films” present “emotionally charged images” without providing any explanation. His immediate gripe is that audience members are led to believe that Israel is “stealing” — yes, he puts quotation marks around the word — Palestinian land, as if to imply Palestinians generously offer their land to Israel for settlement expansion already deemed illegal under the Fourth Geneva Convention.

Surbeck then plays the numbers game by citing the “wave” of suicide bombings that allegedly killed over 1,000. The number is actually 804 deaths over a span of 20 years. But since Surbeck finds it appropriate to bring up statistics, let us remember that in just 22 days — not years but days — starting at the end of 2008, Israel killed over 1,400 Palestinians with missiles, heavy machine-gun fire, and white phosphorous shells haphazardly launched at schools, homes, and other civilian centers. [Read more...]

And so what if this isn’t Iran

The Times of Israel posted three videos of the current Harlem Shake dance craze going viral on YouTube. The first is of the Israeli army’s Artillery Corps. Just under that is a video from Ben Gurion University students performing the same dance routine.

But the third video is has nothing to do with Israel and is, instead, captioned, “Despite the title, this is not the Iranian army”. Although the video itself is titled “Harlem shake Iran Army” it appears to be Norwegian in origin. At about the 20th second mark, a soldier goofily falls out of a window while waving the flag of Norway.

This is nothing more than a petty dig at Iran, and considering how The Times of Israel claims itself to be ”fair, fresh and fast”, I can’t help but to wonder what exactly was the point of the article. To humanize the Israeli military, whose soldiers post disturbing images of aiming guns at children’s heads online? Or to dehumanize Iran for the sake of pushing anti-Iran sentiment and instigate further tension? [Read more...]

America’s only football factory, Palestine’s only keffiyeh factory

Wilson, the official football-maker for the NFL, secured a spot during this year’s Super Bowl to run a rather moving commercial taking viewers inside the only dedicated football factory in the United States where footballs are laced by hand and prepped for play in the championship game.

Imagine what would happen if the factory based in the small town of Ada, Ohio was forced to shut its doors for good or if a foreign army kept customers and materials out. It would be an affront to American culture.

This wouldn’t stop the production of footballs of course, but if this factory was the only football-maker in the country, the only site fitted with the machines necessary to sew, stamp, shape, and lace a football, this would be a different story — a story more like what’s happening to the Herbawi keffiyeh factory in Al-Khalil (Hebron) in the West Bank. [Read more...]

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 3,017 other followers